Understanding as explanatory ability - Deepstash
Understanding as explanatory ability

Understanding as explanatory ability

There are many situations where we can behave flexibly but can't claim to have a deep understanding—for example, teaching someone how to tread water.

Alternatively, we may think that explanation, and not action, is the key principle. For example, the Feynman Technique is an example of a tool that aims at self-explanation as the way to understand something. But, it is not complete, as understanding can always deepen.

107 STASHED

5 LIKES

MORE IDEAS FROM THEARTICLE

There is no singular process behind understanding.

  • Increased and varied exposure to an idea or skill should help to develop most forms of understanding.
  • The flexible action and explanatory ability show some overlap, but there are cases where you could foster one kind but not the other.

Instead of trying to find one way of understanding, we should ask more guided questions about what we want to do with what we learn.

108 STASHED

2 LIKES

Understanding as identifying broad, abstract principles

We may view understanding as noticing deeper principles - the broad patterns that underlie an issue. Understanding is then a mental process rather than an outward result.

Research shows that novices view physics problems in terms of superficial details (pulleys, inclined planes), but experts view the same problems in terms of principles (conservation of energy, momentum).

107 STASHED

3 LIKES

Understanding as flexible action

To understand something means to be able to apply it and various ways. Understanding chess means being able to play well from a variety of different positions. Understanding algebra means solving a wide range of algebra problems.

Experts seem to rely on having many examples in memory to find the correct move.

 

110 STASHED

3 LIKES

We all know the difference between memorising something we don't understand and the satisfaction of genuinely understanding something.

To understand what it means to understand something is less clear. There are a few possibilities of what understanding might mean:

  • Understanding as connected information
  • Understanding as flexible action
  • Understanding as an explanatory ability
  • Understanding as identifying broad, abstract principles
  • Understanding as concrete mental simulation

130 STASHED

9 LIKES

Understanding as connected information

To understand something means having many connections between it and its related ideas.

We develop understanding by drawing relationships between what we already understand and what we are trying to understand. Analogies, metaphors, visualisations and associations can help to connect new and old knowledge. But it may not be sufficient to fully describe what understanding is.

118 STASHED

6 LIKES

Understanding as concrete mental simulation

Understanding can also be the ability to visualise or simulate what's happening in a concrete problem. 

These kinds of simulations played a vital role in the achievements of Albert Einstein and Richard Feynman.

106 STASHED

3 LIKES

Deepstash helps you become inspired, wiser and productive, through bite-sized ideas from the best articles, books and videos out there.

GET THE APP:

RELATED IDEAS

Directness in learning

If you have a concrete objective (speaking a language, passing an exam), how you practice should match the intended use.

An extension of this idea is that learning broadly is a bad idea - that you won't remember "useless" knowledge. But this is false. Having an extensive knowledge base makes learning easier.

180 STASHED

6 LIKES

charlie munger

More mental models mean you have more ways to solve more problems.

Don't you want to know all 25 of them

645 STASHED

80 LIKES

How to build general skills

General skills not only help you with a narrow problem but can be used repeatedly to solve other problems.

But building general skills can be challenging because it is built from many specific ones. If you're prepared to do the work, you can find better ways to learn that can make breadth possible.

240 STASHED

4 LIKES