Burden of Proof: Who Must Prove What?

A key tension in the debate is the burden of proof. Craig argues that the complexity and existence of the universe demand an explanation, and belief in God is the most rational answer. Sinnott-Armstrong, however, shifts the burden, insisting that extraordinary claims, like the existence of God, require extraordinary evidence. This exchange forces readers to consider who must justify their position more rigorously: the believer or the skeptic.