Our response to "A Cryptocurrency Without a Blockchain Has Been Built to Outperform Bitcoin" – MIT Media Lab - Deepstash

Explore the World's Best Ideas

Join today and uncover 100+ curated journeys from 50+ topics. Unlock access to our mobile app with extensive features.

“The rally began in late November, after the IOTA Foundation, the German nonprofit behind the novel cryptocurrency, announced that it was teaming up with several major technology firms to develop a ‘decentralized data marketplace.’” The article goes on to say: “And the high-profile names participating in its data market pilot—including Microsoft, Deutsche Telekom, and Fujitsu—suggest IOTA is onto something.”

Response One:

IOTA’s relationships with top-tier companies continue to be nebulous.

4

40 reads

the protocol was designed specifically for use on connected devices, but nearly all of that information is wasted, sitting in siloed databases and not making money for its owners.

Response Two:

Whether or not IOTA’s ledger is “tamper-proof,” the entire IOTA network went down in November, and was completely inoperable for about three days. That this has never happened in Bitcoin or Ethereum suggests the extent to which the IOTA network relies on the “coordinator”—a single point of failure—and is not truly decentralized.

IOTA developers were able to transfer funds out of users’ IOTA accounts.

4

24 reads

it enables fee-less transactions between the owners of the data and anyone who wants to buy it—and there are plenty of companies that want to get their hands on data.

IOTA uses a “tangle,” which is based on a mathematical concept called a directed acyclic graph.

Response Three:

Orcutt’s claim that IOTA is free of fees is misleading. IOTA users do the proof of work on their own devices, per transaction.

the work required is a fee. Restricting the ways in which the fee can be paid—requiring that the work be done on a user’s own device—doesn’t make it go away.

4

17 reads

“In August, researchers from MIT and Boston University reported that they discovered a “serious vulnerability” in a novel cryptographic technique IOTA was using.

Response Four: 

  1. the flaw was intentional—that it was meant to serve as a form of “copy protection.”
  2. later, he offered a conflicting explanation that he didn’t write the curl at all, but that an AI wrote it.

We do not find either of these explanations convincing, even in isolation. That they contradict each other makes them even less so.

4

18 reads

IDEAS CURATED BY

decebaldobrica

#engineering, #machinelearning and #crypto

Decebal Dobrica's ideas are part of this journey:

Confused About NFTs?

Learn more about technologyandthefuture with this collection

How to create and sell NFTs

The future of NFTs

The benefits and drawbacks of NFTs

Related collections

Read & Learn

20x Faster

without
deepstash

with
deepstash

with

deepstash

Personalized microlearning

100+ Learning Journeys

Access to 200,000+ ideas

Access to the mobile app

Unlimited idea saving

Unlimited history

Unlimited listening to ideas

Downloading & offline access

Supercharge your mind with one idea per day

Enter your email and spend 1 minute every day to learn something new.

Email

I agree to receive email updates