"You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him drink" - Deepstash
"You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him drink"

"You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him drink"

Ultimately, any learner must desire to swallow whatever lesson is being taught. Teachers can offer classes, but they are entirely unable to make students learn, especially not deeply.

The history of pedagogy is primarily about developing techniques to overcome this barrier rather than focusing on character development, which provides a shift in perspective to overcome the obstacle.

15 STASHED

MORE IDEAS FROM THEARTICLE

Educare and educere have their role in human society, yet neither is sufficient for achieving the learner's holistic development. Educare by itself may stifle individual genius and agency, while educere - to draw them out - needs an entirely different approach that demands "student choice."

The problem with both is that education is ultimately passive. Philosophies of education built on either processes start with the educator rather than the learner.

14 STASHED

We think "education" means school

It doesn't. School is hardly eduction.

Education is derived from two Latin roots.

  • Educare, which means to train or to mould.
  • Educere, which means to draw out or to lead out.

19 STASHED

3 LIKES

This point is fixed: people have free will. Any honest philosophy of education must take as a goal to develop people capable of acting deliberately to create their own lives.

Ultimately it is up to the individual to engage and choose what attitude to adopt. Explorare aligns more with this goal while educare or educere cannot. If we are moulded and lead by education, we likely will forget that it is our responsibility to live deliberately.

13 STASHED

How to avoid the instructional fallacy

One possibility is to shift from education to exploration. Explore (explorare in Latin) means to investigate, search out, examine, explore.

Exploring will result in learning. Students may learn "the basics" in the course of their explorations, such as arithmetic while baking or reading while gaming. Learning will take place when the whole person is engaged and interested.

16 STASHED

The two meanings contained in education provide an etymological foundation for debates about conventional and progressive pedagogies.

  • Educare implies that the educator acts upon the learner to shape them into a form determined by the educator. Familiar tools are lectures, worksheets, pneumonic devices, and standardised assessments.
  • Educere implies a process of drawing out, development, awakening. The tools used include Socratic dialogue, deep reading, the arts, any course of action that encourage critical thinking, sharpens the senses, and expands mental space.

14 STASHED

The instructional fallacy is the assumption that if instruction is provided, then children will learn. However, the student does not learn. Even if they can master some concepts and skills temporarily, they usually don't remember them for long because they lack curiosity or continued study that depends on the knowledge.

It's not that instruction is defective, its that it is insufficient.

  • Learners must actively engage in order to learn.
  • They should have a genuine curiosity for the material.
  • They should take ownership of the process.

15 STASHED

Deepstash helps you become inspired, wiser and productive, through bite-sized ideas from the best articles, books and videos out there.

GET THE APP:

RELATED IDEAS

The struggle to learn new things

We tend to learn only the things we were already good at. This creates little bubbles of confidence where we learn, and vast areas we avoid because we’re not sure we can get good at them.

You see this with people who claim they’re “bad at math” or don’t have the “language gene”.

278 STASHED

2 LIKES

Self-Education: The Way Of The Future

Self-learning (also known as autodidacticism) is useful for certification (and fine-tuning) of your existing skills, to be able to learn continuously, and for the cultivation of your curiosity.

It’s essential to move out of the comfort zone and dive into the learning zone.

74 STASHED

Ennui

Ennui is a form of chronic boredom and it usually involves tiredness, dissatisfaction, apathy and feeling that everything is uninteresting and unfulfilling.

336 STASHED

1 LIKE